Hi
I used to trade from https://tv.upstox.com. Where PnL is showing wrong when we buy or sell same strike multiple times.
For. ex. if I have bought 100 qty at 100 price. and sold at 110 so my Profit will be 1000. Now if I bought 100 qty at 200 and price is running at 220. It should show running profit as 2000. But it is showing inaccurate PnL. Please fix this issue as this is making so much confusion as we can not see actual PnL and end up losing trade.
And Need to give suggestion for adding scalping mode in tv.upstox.com where we can quickly buy/sell in fewer clicks. As currently there is no option for partially exiting position. It needs multiple clicks to close position partially which reverse the trade before we can book profit. You can refer to Dhan platform where they have given floating order pad with buy sell and quantity option where we can easily modify quantity and book profit quickly.
1 Like
Hi @Jagdish_j_ptl
The P&L calculation takes previous tradeās numbers also into consideration. This was useful for many users. Weāve noted that this is also a nuisance for the other half. As a solution, weāre developing a switch that could help users to choose the type of P&L they prefer (combined or individual). This is under development and shall be rolled out towards the end of January.
On Scalper mode, this is also in development and will be out soon.
You might have noticed, tv.upstox.com is getting frequent updates (MTM & Exit all, Price Alerts, etc) and we have lots more to build on it. Feel free to share your feedback on anything that we can improvise on!
Thanks for the updates.
Few more suggestions/bugs:
- In tv.upstox.com we can not enter quantity more than freeze limit.
- We need option in settings to set daily loss limit. So that position should auto square off if limit is reached and user should not be able to trade more for some specific time limit.
- There should be option to save daily profit also. I.e. if user has booked 10000 profit and he wants to keep 70% safe and wanted to risk 30% of profit for next trade then it could be manageable from settings to exit from trade if 30% risk is consumed.
- There should be profit lock option that Iāve mentioned multiple time also. Like after initiating trade if price goes in the profitable direction then there should be option in setting that will apply to all trade to lock profit in terms of ticks or price. For example if I have bought option at 100 and price reached at 110 then at least 102 price should be locked auto so that if price touches 102, trade will auto exit, without waiting for stoploss to hit.
- currently after initiating order, if stop loss order is pending then we can not exit position directly. we need to cancel stoploss order first and then we can exit from current position. There should be option so that we can exit current position and cancel existing SL order.
- while creating new order add option to cancel existing pending order. that will help us to place new SL order without cancelling earlier order as modifying existing order takes more time than placing new SL order using instant order.
- Trailing SL should be placed together with buy/sell order. Currently we need to place trailing SL order after our buy/sell order is executed. Which is not feasible in terms of scalping. We need to quick book profit.
1 Like
Thanks for your feedback @Jagdish_j_ptl
Hi @Jagdish_j_ptl
This is ready to go on our end, but the TV library has some exceptions/controls by default that couldnāt be managed. The official TV team has been reached out as they need to enable us full control of the TV positions space. Shall update you once done!
P&L calculation bug was supposed to solved in end of January but still it is showing wrong which is making us close position in loss. Please fix it ASAP on urgent basis. As we do not want to leave Upstox.
Hi @Jagdish_j_ptl
Tv got back to us on this earlier this month itself. Theyāll be allowing this modification on their next release which is tentatively scheduled in mid May.
Once that is done, within a week this should be solved.
Thanks for quick reply. There is also another issue which is when we place SL-Limit order in TV using + symbol and it places order with difference of 0.05 price between trigger and limit price which is being skipped many times when price jumps over it. Please increase gap to at least 5 ticks. i.e. 25 paisa.
1 Like
Any update on this? I am waiting since 6 months
Hi @Jagdish_j_ptl
TV is yet to patch an update for us to be able to do this. Weāre waiting too. A couple more features are dependant on this as well.
Shall keep you posted once this is ready.
Wrong PnL issue is only in Upstox tv platform. I have checked in AngelOne and Dhan platform it is showing correct so I donāt understand why Tradingview is doing this to Upstox?
Hi @Jagdish_j_ptl
Yes, this patch from TV has been released earlier this month. Weāll have it fixed on our platforms soon!
1 Like
Hi @MohitGolecha
Can you please give me timeline for this fix? As this is really disturbing trading decision. Last Friday I couldnāt book profit and position needed to be exited on loss because your chart was showing +500 profit where it was actually -100.
The P&L calculation takes previous tradeās numbers also into consideration. This was useful for many users. Weāve noted that this is also a nuisance for the other half. As a solution, weāre developing a switch that could help users to choose the type of P&L they prefer (combined or individual). This is under development and shall be rolled out towards the end of January.
Hi @MohitGolecha
Couple of things from my end
- P&L as individual is something I would prefer.
The current method of showing the price as average of both open and closed positions is making me do mental calculations to put stop loss and profit as per running trades. Once this is individual, I donāt have to think about the exited positions. I just need to focus on the running positions.
- TradingView already has the functionality to show positions on the chart as shown in the image below. Anyway to enable this in upstox trading view?
Orders on chart helps me to review the trades after the close of the trade and also at the end of the day.
1 Like
They have added chart replay feature on TV. In that they are showing blue and read arrow so this can be easily added on chart. And this will be very helpful.
Hi @Jagdish_j_ptl @harsha25
Will be done in a week - The price line on the position!
On the position history, this has been developed and is under testing!
1 Like
Please do this also if possible.
Please clarify what will be done in a week? Price averaging issue or second option which @harsha25 has mentioned?
